MGH Psychiatry


Massachusetts General
Hospital


Department of Psychiatry

Residency Training Program

This elective seminar meets the third Tuesday of the month, September through June in the Hackett Room, starting at 6:30 pm. It is open to all trainees -- PGY1-4, interns, fellows, BPSI candidates, and recent training program graduates.

A pdf of each webpage is attached to its footer.




Home‎ > ‎

Stay, Illusion!

Hamlet:  Selected Key Passages
Jenkins Arden Shakespeare, acts, scenes, lines
and the Enfolded Hamlet, through line numbers

Stay, Illusion.  I. i. 72-147 -- 85-141


85           Hor             This bodes some strange eruption to our state.
86            Mar           Good, now [1] sit down and tell me, he-that-knows,
87                               Why this same strict and most observant watch
88                               So nightly toils the subject of the land, [2]
89                               And why such daily cast of brazen cannon
90                               And foreign mart for implements of war, [3]
91                               Why such impress[4] of shipwrights, whose sore task
92                               Does not divide the Sunday from the week.
93                               What might be toward[5] that this sweaty haste
94                               Doth make the night joint laborer with the day,
95                               Who is't that can inform me?
96            Hor            That can I.
97                               At least the whisper goes so. Our last king,
98                               Whose image even but now appeared to us,
99                               Was as you know by Fortinbras[6] of Norway
100                             Thereto pricked on[7] by a most emulate[8] pride,
101                             Dared to the combat; in which our valiant Hamlet
102                              (For so this side of our known world esteemed him)
103                              Did slay this Fortinbras, who by a sealed compact
104                              Well ratified by law and heraldry,
105                              Did forfeit with his life all those his lands
106                              Which he stood seized of, to the conqueror --
107                              Against the which a moiety competent[9]
108                              Was gaged[10] by our king, which had returned
109                              To the inheritance of Fortinbras,
110                              Had he been vanquisher. As by the same covenant
111                              And carriage[11] of the article designed,
112                              His fell to Hamlet. Now sir, young Fortinbras
113                              Of unimproved mettle,[12] hot and full,
114                              Hath in the skirts[13] of Norway here and there
115                              Sharked[14] up a list of lawless[15] resolutes[16]
116                              For food and diet to some enterprise
117                              That hath a stomach in't,[17] which is no other --
118                              As it doth well appear unto our state --
119                              But to recover of us by strong hand
120                              And terms compulsatory, those foresaid lands
121                              So by his father lost. And this, I take it,
122                              Is the main motive of our preparations,
123                              The source of this our watch, and the chief head
124                              Of this posthaste[18]and rummage[19] in the land.[20]
124+1            Bar       I think it be no other but e'en so.
124+2                         Well may it sort[21] that this portentous figure
124+3                         Comes armed through our watch so like the king
124+4                         That was -- and is -- the question of these wars.
124+5            Hor      A mote it is to trouble the mind's eye:
124+6                         In the most high and palmy[22] state of Rome,
124+7                        A little ere the mightiest Julius fell,
124+8                        The graves stood tenantless and the sheeted[23]dead
124+9                         Did squeak and gibber in the Roman streets --
124+10                      As stars with trains of fire and dews of blood --
124+11                       Disasters[24] in the sun -- and the moist star[25]
124+12                      Upon whose influence Neptune's empire stands,
124+13                      Was sick almost to doomsday with eclipse.
124+14                      And even the like precurse[26] of fear events --
124+15                      As harbingers preceding still[27] the fates
124+16                      And prologue to the omen coming on --
124+17                      Have heaven and earth together demonstrated
124+18                      Unto our climatures[28] and countrymen.[29]
125            Enter Ghost again
126                             But soft, behold, lo where it comes again!
127                             I'll cross it though it blast me![30]--Stay, Illusion!
                 It spreads his arms[31]
128                             If thou[32] hast any sound or use of voice,
129                             Speak to me. If there be any good thing to be done
130                             That may to thee do ease, and grace to me,
130                             Speak to me.
131                             If thou art privy to thy country's fate
132                             Which happily foreknowing may avoid,
132                             O speak.
133                             Or if thou hast uphoarded in thy life
134                             Extorted treasure in the womb of earth
135                             For which, they say, you spirits oft walk[33] in death,
            The cock crows
136                            Speak of it. Stay and speak -- stop it Marcellus!
137            Mar         Shall I strike it with my partisan?[34]
138            Hor         Do, if it will not stand.
139            Bar         'Tis here.
140           Hor          'Tis here.
141           Mar         'Tis gone.
            Exit Ghost



[1] "good now" can mean "please" or "very good" but Quarto 1 separates them with a comma, which is more playable

[2] why so late toil the subjects of this land

[3] bronze cannon and shopping for armaments

[4] forced service

[5] soon happening

[6] Fortinbras = Fr., Strong-Arm

[7] spurred

[8] envious

[9] similar portion

[10] pledged

[11] terms

[12] crude courage

[13] far reaches

[14] indiscriminately gobbled

[15] can also be "landless resolutes," which makes Fortinbras seem a bit less barbarous

[16] desperadoes

[17] requiring courage

[18] galloping haste

[19] uproar

[20] A few lines ago, Horatio gave his comrades physical descriptions of the king on two occasions. Later, he will say that he saw the late king once (TLN 375). Now he has just described hand-to-hand combat between King Hamlet and the king of Norway. So Horatio could not have seen this fight, nor the sledded Poles on the ice.

[21] it may well be why

[22] prosperous

[23] enshrouded

[24] There is a missing word or line, but the sense is that the stars and sun foretold disasters.

[25] the moon

[26] same portents

[27] always

[28] regions

[29] The scholar Horatio is teaching about Rome -- maybe his speeches about Norway and Poles on the ice are just tropes. In a way, it seems like eye-witness testimony, but Horatio may be using poetic license like a university don.

[30] I will face it, cross its path.

[31] reading from the 2nd Quarto

[32] By convention, sixteenth century English speakers addressed God (and the supernatural) with the intimate pronoun -- thee, thou, thine -- which later Hamlet will use with the Ghost.

[33] Horatio knows the reasons the dead are restless:  to finish an incomplete good deed or to repair an ill deed; to warn of impending catastrophe; or to visit stolen or ill-gotten gold -- standard Elizabethan lore.

[34] pike

 




TLN 85-141

85 This bodes some strange eruption to our state.
86  Mar.
Good now sit downe, and tell me he that knowes,
87 Why this same strikt and most obseruant watch
88 So nightly toiles the subiect of the land,
89 And {with} <why> such dayly {cost} <Cast> of brazon Cannon
90 And forraine marte, for implements of warre,
91 Why such impresse of ship-writes, whose sore taske
92 Does not deuide the Sunday from the weeke,
93 What might be toward that this sweaty hast
94 Doth make the night ioynt labourer with the day,
95 Who ist that can informe mee?
96  Hora.
That can I.
97 <nn5
> At least the whisper goes so; our last King,
98 Whose image euen but now appear'd to vs,
99 Was as you knowe by Fortinbrasse
of Norway,
100 Thereto prickt on by a most emulate pride
101 Dar'd to the combat; in which our valiant Hamlet
,
102 (For so this side of our knowne world esteemd him)
103 Did slay this Fortinbrasse
, who by a seald compact
104 Well ratified by lawe and {heraldy} <Heraldrie,>
105 {B2v
} Did forfait (with his life) all {these} <those> his lands
106 Which he stood seaz'd {of} <on>, to the conquerour.
107 Against the which a moitie competent
108 Was gaged by our King, which had {returne} <return'd>
109 To the inheritance of Fortinbrasse
,
110 Had he bin vanquisher; as by the same {comart,} <Cou'nant>
111 And carriage of the article desseigne,
112 His fell to Hamlet; now Sir, young Fortinbrasse

113 Of vnimprooued mettle, hot and full,
114 Hath in the skirts of Norway
heere and there
115 Sharkt vp a list of {lawelesse} <Landlesse> resolutes
116 For foode and diet to some enterprise
117 That hath a stomacke in't, which is no other
118 {As} <And> it doth well appeare vnto our state
119 But to recouer of vs by strong hand
120 And tearmes {compulsatory} <Compulsatiue>, those foresaid lands
121 So by his father lost; and this I take it,
122 Is the maine motiue of our preparations
123 The source of this our watch, and the chiefe head
124 Of this post hast and Romadge in the land.
124+1 { Bar
. I thinke it be no other, but enso;}
124+2 {Well may it sort that this portentous figure}
124+3 {Comes armed through our watch so like the King}
124+4 {That was and is the question of these warres.}
124+5 { Hora
. A moth it is to trouble the mindes eye:}
124+6 {In the most high and palmy state of Rome,}
124+7 {A little ere the mightiest Iulius
fell}
124+8 {The graues stood tennatlesse, and the sheeted dead}
124+9 {Did squeake and gibber in the Roman streets}
124+10 {As starres with traines of fier, and dewes of blood}
124+11 {Disasters in the sunne; and the moist starre,}
124+12 {Vpon whose influence Neptunes
Empier stands,}
124+13 {Was sicke almost to doomesday with eclipse.}
124+14 {And euen the like precurse of feare euents}
124+15 {As harbindgers preceading still the fates}
124+16 {And prologue to the Omen
comming on}
124+17 {Haue heauen and earth together demonstrated}
124+18 {Vnto our Climatures and countrymen.}
125              Enter Ghost
<againe>.
126 {B3
} But soft, behold, loe where it comes againe
127 Ile crosse it though it blast mee: stay illusion,           {It spreads
}
128 If thou hast any sound or vse of voyce,                 {his armes.
}
129 Speake to me, if there be any good thing to be done
130 That may to thee doe ease, and grace to mee,
130 Speake to me.
131 If thou art priuie to thy countries fate
132 Which happily foreknowing may auoyd
132 O speake:
133 Or if thou hast vphoorded in thy life
134 Extorted treasure in the wombe of earth
135 For which they say {your} <you> spirits oft walke in death. {The cocke
}
136 Speake of it, stay and speake, stop it Marcellus
. {crowes.}
137  Mar.
Shall I strike <at> it with my partizan?
138  Hor
. Doe if it will not stand.
139  Bar.
Tis heere.
140  Hor
. Tis heere.
141  Mar.
Tis gone. <Exit Ghost.> 


NOTES

Denmark is again on the verge of war with Norway, the country is filled with anxiety and anticipation. Horatio and his companions know that armaments are being manufactured seven days a week, night and day, armies levied, preparations for war proceeding furiously. Now an image of the late king has appeared in full battle dress. What does this foretell about war and the fate of Denmark?

124+5 Unlike the others, Horatio has Latin (note the pun: H + oration). The language of scholars is also the language of exorcism -- demons can best be addressed in Latin. His reflex under stress, he continues to teach his anxious friends as if they were in a classroom (and he must cordially wish he were somewhere safe). This time it's a classics lesson. He reaches back, not just thirty years, but back to ancient Rome -- and to another ruler dead, another throne usurped. For the second time in a few lines, Horatio alludes to usurpation.

Brave and knowledgeable, he is the man to bring on a mission -- Elizabethan audiences knew that crossing the path of a supernatural being courts destruction. ("I'll cross it" has nothing to do with making the sign of the cross. Besides, Horatio styles himself as pagan, not Christian. Moreover, Horatio knows how to ask unquiet spirits what they need. It's important here for the director to decide how to play this face-off between man and ghost. The Second Quarto says "It spreads his armes," TLN 126-7. Horatio's gestures could be warding off the Ghost, to stop it approaching -- or begging it not to leave -- or both.

127 Time stands still. Stay, Illusion! Horatio here speaks for all humankind --  Stay, Illusion!

While the apparition seems to be the late king bearing a prophecy of war, it might be an unclean spirit. Pagan notions of the supernatural blend with the narrative of Christianity. Later in the scene after the Ghost has left, the thoughts of the three men, relieved now to be safe, turn to the season of Advent. These passages further characterize Horatio:  I do in part believe it. Is Horatio saying that he believes a part of the story or that part of him believes the story? At first skeptical of its existence, Horatio now has an intuition:  the Illusion will speak to Hamlet.

Time flies in situations of high emotion: Only 160 or so lines elapse between "midnight" and "dawn," yet the audience accepts the passage of five hours as perfectly real, and this happens the following night as well. Here, both of the Ghost's entrances interrupt a narrated episode in the past tense, so two "clocks" are ticking -- one in the oral history being reported, and one that starts the instant the Ghost stops the first clock. But present time compressed into the narrative past tense becomes only a moment. Shakespeare creates a world onstage so real that its version of elapsed time is the one we accept, not audience-time.

The first scene ends with a dozen questions raised and the audience honed to the edge of suspense. The character of Horatio has been established, a renaissance man living the examined life. (Hamlet is set in medieval Denmark, not the Renaissance, but Shakespeare delights in anachronisms. He seems deliberately to leave time "out of joint." As Bloom puts it, sometimes he was "... wonderfully careless on matters of time and space."  Poem Unlimited, p 6.)



Note on the text:    The primary source here is the Enfolded Hamlet of Bernice W. Kliman, ©1996, a conflation of the 1604/05 Second Quarto and the First Folio of 1623. (at www.leoyan.com/global-language.com/ENFOLDED/) Through Line Numbers (TLNs) are based on the Folio. Depending on what readings seem most sensible and accessible to the modern ear, textual choices have been made on a line-by-line, within-line, and word-by-word basis from the melded version. The First Quarto of 1603 has been consulted where possible in an attempt to resolve conflicts in meaning between the Folio and Second Quarto. Spelling is updated to US English, and each line has been repunctuated in accordance with my understanding of the text -- J Groves

Č
ĉ
ď
James Groves,
Mar 7, 2010 6:07 PM
Ċ
ď
James Groves,
Aug 29, 2009 12:20 PM
ĉ
ď
James Groves,
Mar 7, 2010 6:08 PM
Ċ
ď
James Groves,
Aug 29, 2009 12:19 PM
ĉ
ď
James Groves,
Mar 7, 2010 6:07 PM
Ċ
ď
James Groves,
Aug 29, 2009 12:19 PM